In 1955, the United States deported a rocket scientist named Qian Xuesen, calling him a security threat. Seventy years later, it’s preparing to do the same - this time, to a quarter million Chinese students. The New York Times just published a rare, honest piece calling this out for what it is: a self-inflicted wound, driven by xenophobia and Cold War paranoia. Again.
Let’s rewind.
Who Was Qian Xuesen?
Qian wasn’t just some scientist. He was a founding genius of American rocketry, a Caltech professor, and worked alongside Theodore von Kármán, one of the fathers of modern aerospace. He was instrumental in the early development of jet propulsion, missile systems, and yes - helped lay the groundwork for what would become NASA.
He even contributed to the Manhattan Project, America’s top-secret effort to build the atomic bomb.
By all accounts, Qian should’ve been an American hero.
But in 1950, during the height of McCarthyism, he was labeled a “Communist sympathizer,” had his security clearance stripped, was placed under house arrest, and eventually deported. America thought it was ridding itself of a threat
.
It was actually giving China a gift.
What Did Qian Do After He Returned to China?
Everything America feared.
He became the father of China’s missile and space programs. He helped China develop its first intercontinental ballistic missile, its first nuclear bomb, and in 1970, its first satellite, Dongfanghong-1, went into orbit - under his leadership
.
In one stroke, Qian Xuesen transformed China from a backward, war-torn nation into a rising technological power. And he did it because America pushed him away.
Even Dan Kimball, U.S. Navy Secretary at the time, admitted:
“It was the stupidest thing the U.S. ever did.”
He wasn’t wrong.
Fast Forward to 2025: Same Paranoia, Bigger Mistake
Now, here we are again.
On May 29, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced plans to revoke the visas of Chinese students, especially those in STEM fields. That’s over 250,000 students, making up the backbone of American science and research programs.
Universities are already panicking. STEM research relies heavily on Chinese graduate students. So does funding. Tuition. Innovation. It’s no exaggeration to say that American labs would collapse without them.
And yet, here comes the hammer.
Rubio claims these students might “steal technology.” Sound familiar?
That’s the exact accusation they made against Qian in 1950.
And just like back then, the U.S. is so obsessed with stopping China that it’s willing to shoot itself in the foot. Again.
“Kick Us Out? We’ll Build Our Own Future.”
This time, though, China’s not weak. It’s not 1955. It has Beidou, 5G, quantum communication, and AI breakthroughs. It doesn’t need permission from the West anymore.
Chinese students online are boldly declaring:
“Visa bans will only make us go home and help China rise faster.”
They’re not wrong either. Programs like the Thousand Talents Plan have already drawn back waves of elite talent. Many of China’s top tech achievements came from people who were educated in the U.S. - and then left, either voluntarily or not.
So now, instead of just one Qian Xuesen, America is giving China thousands.
America Thinks It’s Winning a Cold War. It’s Not.
Let’s be blunt: xenophobia isn’t strategy. It’s fear dressed up as patriotism.
The U.S. calls itself a “beacon of freedom,” yet it's gutting its universities, alienating its allies, and handing off talent to Europe and China on a silver platter. All in the name of national security.
Even The New York Times, not known for radical takes, admits:
“Decisions born of xenophobia will forever reshape the world order.”
They’re right. But they stop short of saying what really needs to be said:
This isn’t just shortsighted. It’s stupid. Again.
Final Thought
Qian Xuesen’s story is a mirror. A painful one.
In 1955, America saw a Chinese genius and said: “We don’t trust you.”
In 2025, it’s doing it again, just multiplied by 250,000.
And just like before, it will regret it.
But China? China will welcome them back. Just like it did with Qian. And history will once again prove: when the U.S. expels brilliance out of fear, someone else will pick it up - and build the future with it.
Want more political reality checks like this?
Subscribe or upgrade - this Substack is 100% reader-supported. No ads. No fluff.
