0:00
/
0:00

Why Is America Silencing Its Own People… for Someone Else?Another Country?

Project Esther isn't about public safety. It's about suppressing dissent in the name of a foreign ally and punishing Americans for speaking out.

What Is Project Esther?

In late 2024, the Heritage Foundation, a powerful conservative think tank in Washington, D.C., quietly released a document called Project Esther.
Publicly, it’s described as a “national strategy to combat antisemitism.” But underneath that label is something else entirely:
A domestic suppression playbook that targets students, teachers, and activists—especially those who speak out against Israel’s government or support Palestinian rights.

The document invents a new label: the Hamas Support Network (HSN).
This doesn’t refer to actual militant organizations.
It refers to college clubs, professors, protest organizers, NGOs, and even social media users who express solidarity with Palestine.

This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Then it offers a blueprint for how the U.S. government should respond:

  • Revoke student visas

  • Deny protest permits

  • Freeze funding to universities and student groups

  • Monitor online speech for “anti-Israel” views

  • Use laws like RICO and FARA, originally designed for organized crime and foreign agents, to charge political activists

  • Pressure schools to fire or silence faculty with “bias”

Some of these recommendations are already being carried out.
In 2025, we’ve seen:

  • Students deported or blocked from re-entering the U.S.

  • Professors fired or suspended

  • Campus organizations defunded

  • Protests shut down

  • People questioned by federal agents because of what they posted online


What Is It Really About?

Let’s be honest. This isn’t about fighting hate.
It’s about controlling speech.
It’s about making it dangerous to challenge the U.S.-Israel relationship, especially if you're young, progressive, or part of an immigrant community.

Project Esther doesn’t focus on hate groups or violent extremists.
It focuses on ideas.
On political expression.
On peaceful protest.

It reframes criticism of a foreign government as a national security issue.
It encourages federal agencies to act, not because someone broke a law, but because they broke a narrative.

This is not a culture war. It is a legal war.
And the target is the American public.


Why Is the U.S. Doing This… for Israel?

Here’s the question no one wants to answer:
Why is the United States rewriting its domestic policies to shield a foreign country from criticism?

When students get deported for holding signs...
When professors get fired for questioning war policy...
When public funds are pulled because of speech...

That’s not national security. That’s political enforcement.

And it’s not coming from the public.
It’s not coming from voters.
It’s coming from lobbyists, think tanks, political donors, and entrenched influence networks that have made unconditional support for Israel a core requirement in American politics.

If you break that rule, even peacefully, you pay the price.

This is how democratic societies slide toward authoritarianism.
Not through tanks in the street.
But through policies drafted behind closed doors, implemented through bureaucracy, and shielded from public scrutiny.


Final Thought

Project Esther is not a one-off document.
It reflects a broader shift, where American institutions are being used to punish American citizens.
Not for harming anyone, but for expressing the "wrong" political views.

That shift should concern anyone who still believes in free speech, free assembly, or academic freedom.

Fairness, justice, and liberty are more than ideals.
They only exist when people are allowed to speak, organize, and dissent.

And right now, that right is shrinking.


📄 Project Esther – Heritage Foundation PDF:
https://www.heritage.org/sites/default/files/2024-10/Project%20Esther.pdf

Leave a comment

Discussion about this video

User's avatar