Discussion about this post

User's avatar
钟建英's avatar

Hi, this is arguably the most insightful post I have seen this year. May I suggest that you repost this every year in its original form with whatever supplementary comments you wish to add?

Jeremy Smith's avatar

This is a fascinating insight into Chinese working practices Neil that really does help ‘move beyond the slogans’ as you put it.

I wonder if you could take this analysis further sometime and do a piece on the extent to which Marxist principles are enacted through these relationships between business and the modern Chinese Communist Party

From my Western perspective I’ve always thought of Marxism and Communism as different sides of the same coin. But obviously it’s all too often just about trying to frame my own abstract thinking rather than dealing with concrete realities.

It would be insightful I think to hear your thoughts on the usefulness (or otherwise) of Marxist ideas in Chinese workplaces that have the mechanisms you described here, especially with regards to pay and working conditions.

Are workers more looked after under the Chinese system? Or is it more about personal sacrifice to the Party? Or are these framings just tropes in fact?

Big ups.

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?